Nintendo sues PalWorld developer PocketPlayer
Memorization PalworldAn indie video game from Japanese developer PocketPair that Took the gaming world by storm when it launched earlier this year? It's an action survival game that clearly took inspiration from Pokemon in which the player is dropped into an open world environment and is tasked with capturing “palms” and using them as work horses to build fortresses, weapons and the like, as well as fighting your enemies. Palworld And Pokemon The game was striking enough for it to be loved so much”.PokemoThe song was criticized by its fans for being “all about guns”. Palworld It was a huge hit upon its release in January, selling over eight million copies in its first six days and 2,101,867 top concurrent players On Steam, just a little below Current cognition Black Myth: Wukong braid,
#palworld Over 8 million copies sold in less than 6 days!
thank you so much!!
As mentioned earlier, we continue to work at full speed to fix bugs and issues!
Thanks for your support!#pocketpair pic.twitter.com/4PLB1J4CYH— Palworld (@Palworld_EN) January 25, 2024
At the time, there was speculation that Nintendo, which owns The Verge, Pokemon The company may sue PocketPlayer for trademark infringement because the Pals are so similar to Pokemon. There were some indications that this could happen. One modder was planning to create one Palworld Mod that will let gamers play as Ash and other Pokémon characters, but Nintendo promptly banned it. He also said that issued a statement in January that they would “investigate any violations of intellectual property rights” and “take appropriate measures.” But that was the last anyone heard of it, and PocketPlayer said they would “not take any action.”Legal review approvedbefore the release of PalworldTherefore it was assumed that the whole matter was over.
Well, obviously, that hasn't happened, because Nintendo is now suing PocketPlayer for infringement of patent rights. They and Pokemon The company is seeking an “injunction against the infringement and compensation for damages” because Palworld “infringes multiple patent rights.” Why did this suddenly happen nine months later? Palworld came into the scene? Well, that's the part that makes Nintendo suspicious. According to legal documents (courtesy of X User God's Little Rejects), Nintendo and Pokemon The company filed a patent for Poké Balls in May, citing game designer Kazumasa Iwao — an employee of Game Freak, which co-owns The Game. Pokemon The company – along with Nintendo and Creatures Inc. – is listed as the inventor of Poké Balls. The patent includes pointing and launching an item or character as a video game mechanic; in other words, they argued that if gamers can point and launch anything in your video game, you are ripping off Nintendo and the Pokemon The company applied for a patent. And the court agreed and granted the patent in August.
Nintendo is so angry that PalWorld couldn't be sued on design copyright grounds, they created a patent for the game mechanic “pointing and aiming an item for launch”, specifically to sue PalWorld. Nintendo fans are so stupid they think this is for trademark infringement https://t.co/9MKFNFPIiM pic.twitter.com/DDMBi4z94z
— God's Little Rejects (@destructionset) September 19, 2024
Now that this is all on the legal record, they are suing PocketPlayer and claiming that the indie studio copied pointing and launching from them, basically saying that they copied the Poké Balls. PocketPlayer responded to the lawsuit, but they didn't say much other than to point out how unfortunate the situation is:
in connection with the lawsuit
A patent infringement suit was filed against our company yesterday.
We have been notified of this lawsuit and will initiate appropriate legal proceedings and investigations regarding the patent infringement claims.
At this point, we are unaware…
— Palworld (@Palworld_EN) September 19, 2024
Former Blizzard Producer Mark Kern There is a good saying about this: Pokemon It's been going on for a while, but Nintendo and Pokemon The company decided to patent this game mechanic just a few months later Palworld released and became a huge hit. He's right, and that makes me think that PocketPaper was correct in saying it was legally covered, and Nintendo had no leg to stand on in court. So, they invented one, filed a patent after the fact and used it to sue so they could shut down a game and its developer who were making money off of something that satirized one of their brands. It's dirty pool, and while I'm not a legal expert, I don't know how it could hold up in court. Palworld It was developed and issued before this patent even existed.
Palworld emerged in February.
The patent about Poké Balls was filed in May.
The patent was granted in August.
Nintendo sued Palworld the following month.
Guys, this is Nintendo using the law to kill an indie studio that embarrassed them by making better Pokemon… pic.twitter.com/Z2ovQ3W3rw
— Grumz (@grumz) September 19, 2024
I agree with Kern; Nintendo is trying to shut down a promising indie competitor before it becomes too big a thorn in their side. And if they don't shut down PocketPlayer, at least they'll get them into so much legal trouble that the next studio will refuse to take a chance on them in the marketplace. Also, as Madam Savvy One comment said, Patenting game mechanics can limit the number of games that can be developed. These things build upon each other with each new incarnation; for example, what if someone had patented first-person shooting? We'd still be playing it Labyrinth Warnever found Wolfenstein, Apocalypse, Dutyor – don't make me cry – Eye of GoldDepending on what happens in this case, gaming could be very different in the future.
Very lame. I don't think game mechanics should be patented…
This could change the way patents are handled in Japan, making it the most important case ever in the creative industry.
I wish they would just give money to play games…
— Savvy (@MadamSavvy) September 19, 2024
Tell us what you think about Nintendo suing PocketPlayer? Palworld In the comments!
,
Get Your Geeks + Gamers Merch Here,